Tags are the restaurant’s own; confirm allergies with staff.
No dish on this menu carries every tag you picked.
8 dishes
A vibrant pizza topped with signature sweet pizza sauce, melted Wisconsin cheese blend, savory mushrooms, crisp red onions, fresh green peppers, ripe tomatoes, and briny black olives
Ask for it without the cheese.
A fresh blend of Iceberg & Spinach topped with Cheddar Cheese, Tomatoes, Broccoli, & Onions
Ask for it without the cheddar cheese.
Four chewy cookies baked with rich, dark chocolate chunks
Ask whether it is made with milk, butter or egg.
Freshly baked until golden brown then served with sweet vanilla icing
Ask whether it contains butter, milk or egg.
Our Cauliflower Crust is gluten free and lower in carbs. Available in 10" only
Ask whether the dough has milk in it, and to leave off any dairy cheese.
Wisconsin cheese blend, sautéed mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives, lettuce, tomatoes & creamy Italian dressing on a toasted roll
Ask for it without the cheese.
Pick up to 3 of your favorite pizza toppings!
Is the dough made with milk or egg?
Mushrooms, Red Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, & Tomatoes
Ask whether the dough contains milk, butter or egg, and whether it comes with cheese.
35 dishes
A handcrafted classic loaded with flavor. Topped with bold pepperoni, sausage, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, and red onions over our signature sweet sauce and premium mozzarella blend. The perfect balance of meat and veggies on every slice
Turn up the heat with Dante’s Peak — a fiery combination of bold pepperoni, zesty sausage, banana peppers, red onions, and fresh tomatoes. Built on our signature sweet sauce and melted mozzarella for a spicy-satisfying bite in every slice
A meat lover’s dream. Loaded with bold pepperoni, savory Italian sausage, diced ham, crispy bacon, and hearty meatballs — all layered over our signature sweet sauce and melted Wisconsin cheese blend. Every bite delivers handcrafted, crave-worthy flavor
A bold twist on a timeless favorite. Layered with our Wisconsin cheese blend, old world style pepperoni, and creamy fresh mozzarella balls — all atop Romeo’s signature sweet pizza sauce. Rustic, rich, and handcrafted to perfection
Get ready for a pepperoni lover’s dream. The Pepperoni Feast piles on extra bold pepperoni and extra Wisconsin cheese blend over our signature sweet pizza sauce. Baked to perfection for a crispy, cheesy, flavor-packed slice in every bite
Enjoy our Buffalo Chicken Pizza made with house-made ranch bacon sauce, grilled chicken marinated in mild buffalo sauce, extra Wisconsin cheese blend, topped with a mild buffalo sauce swirl and zesty Romano cheese seasoning. Perfect for fans of flavorful, spicy chicken pizza
A savory pizza featuring creamy ranch bacon sauce, melted Wisconsin cheese blend, hearty sausage, sweet caramelized onions, roasted red potatoes, and crunchy ranch-flavored almonds
A flavorful pizza topped with tender broccoli, fresh spinach, juicy tomatoes, and a rich Wisconsin cheese blend, all served on a buttery garlic sauce base
A hearty deep-dish pizza layered with your choice of up to two toppings, filled with Wisconsin cheese blend, and topped with provolone, pizza sauce, and Romano cheese
Hand-stretched golden breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and Romano seasoning. Served warm with Romeo’s Signature Sweet Sauce for dipping
Hand-stretched breadsticks topped with a blend of sharp cheddar and Wisconsin cheese, then baked until bubbly. Served with Romeo’s Signature Sweet Sauce
Hand-stretched breadsticks topped with our cheddar & Wisconsin cheese blend and crispy bacon pieces. Served with Romeo’s Signature Sweet Sauce on the side
A fresh blend of Iceberg & Spinach, topped with Ham, Pepperoni, Salami, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Red Onions, & Cheddar Cheese
Ham, Turkey, Green Peppers, Broccoli, Wisconsin Cheese Blend, & Cheddar Cheese atop our Garden Salad
Grilled Chicken, Bacon Pieces, & Ranch-Flavored Almonds atop our Garden Salad
Start with dough made fresh in-house daily, choose your crust, and load on our signature sweet sauce and premium Wisconsin cheese—then top with your favorite meats, veggies, and more. Available in Small (10″-6 slices), Medium (12″-8), Large (14″-10) & X-Large (16″-12)
Enjoy our mozzarella-filled “Loaded” crust—available on Large (14″-10 slices) only—paired with dough made fresh daily, signature sweet sauce, Wisconsin cheese blend, and limitless toppings of your choice
Perfect for groups—choose your toppings on our half-sheet (20 slices, serves 6-8) or full-sheet (40 slices, serves 12-16), each with dough made fresh daily, signature sweet sauce & premium Wisconsin cheese
Enjoy a 10″ gluten-free crust made to the same standards as our regular dough, topped with signature sweet sauce, Wisconsin cheese blend, and your choice of fresh toppings—perfect for gluten-sensitive diets
Ham, salami, pepperoni, red onions, banana peppers, Wisconsin cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes & creamy Italian dressing on a toasted Amoroso roll
Roasted turkey breast, Wisconsin cheese blend, crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes & creamy mayo on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Premium meatballs, signature sweet sauce & melted Wisconsin cheese blend on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Authentic sliced steak, sautéed green peppers, red onions, cheddar & Wisconsin cheese blend on a toasted Amoroso roll
Breaded chicken tossed in hot or medium buffalo sauce, Wisconsin cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes & ranch dressing on a toasted Amoroso roll
Grilled chicken breast, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & Wisconsin cheese blend on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Ham, turkey, pepperoni, salami & Wisconsin cheese blend piled high with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Ham, turkey, bacon, Wisconsin cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Seasoned steak patties, mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, Wisconsin cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Seasoned steak patties, salami, red onions, Wisconsin cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes & creamy Italian dressing on a toasted 10″ Amoroso roll
Available in 8, 12 & 20-wing orders. Served with sauce on the side: Garlic Parmesan, Medium Buffalo, Sweet Chili, Smokehouse BBQ, Spicy Garlic or Hot Buffalo
Available in 5, 10, 15, 20 & 25-wing orders. Bone-in wings hand-spun in your choice of Garlic Parmesan, Medium Buffalo, Sweet Chili, Smokehouse BBQ, Spicy Garlic or Hot Buffalo—tossed in the sauce for maximum flavor
Extra Pepperoni & Wisconsin Cheese Blend
Ham, Salami & Pepperoni
Ham, Banana Peppers & Red Onions
Fresh Mozzarella, Cheddar, & Wisconsin Cheese Blend
1 dish