Tags are the restaurant’s own; confirm allergies with staff.
No dish on this menu carries every tag you picked.
7 dishes
Ask what it is made with. The menu does not list the ingredients.
Ask what it is made with. The menu does not list the ingredients.
The Cone Party cake brings joy to young and old with its sprinkle-filled mini sugar cones! Available in dairy and vegan versions, each cake comes with: One layer of Vanilla ice cream One layer of Chocolate ice cream Two layers of homemade brownies (dairy) or vegan, gluten-free chocolate chip cookies from our local partner You’re a Cookie! Vanilla whipped cream or vegan buttercream frosting Mini sugar cones Rainbow sprinkles Your message written in our homemade non-dairy fudge sauce Customizations offered below bear additional charges. 6" round cake feeds 8–12 9" round cake feeds 18–22 12" round cake feeds 40–50
Ask for the vegan or vegetarian version, the menu says they make one.
The Bartleby’s Lace design is our take on the classic cake decorating style called cornelli lace, with freehand, organic squiggles and dots forming a unique pattern each time we make it. We paired our favorite decorating technique with your two favorite ice cream flavors to create a cake that's undeniable! Each Bartleby’s Lace cake comes with: One layer of Honeycomb ice cream One layer of Cookies and Cream ice cream Two layers of our homemade chocolate chip cookies Chocolate whipped cream or vegan buttercream frosting Homemade cookie dough balls (vegan and gluten-free) Chopped Oreos A dotted lace pattern and your message written in our homemade non-dairy fudge sauce As described, this cake contains dairy, eggs, wheat, and soy. Customizations offered below may contain other allergens. 6" round cake feeds 8–12 9" round cake feeds 18–22 12" round cake feeds 40–50
Ask for the vegan or vegetarian version, the menu says they make one.
The ice cream cake of your dreams, built to your specifications! You can choose: One or two flavors of ice cream One or two baked goods to be crumbled under each ice cream layer Vanilla or chocolate whipped cream or vegan buttercream, with food coloring if you like Your message in our homemade non-dairy fudge sauce As many toppings as you want! Check out our signature designs for a few popular special options! 6" round serves 8–12 9" round serves 18–22 12" round serves 40–50
Ask for the vegan or vegetarian version, the menu says they make one.
Ask what it is made with. The menu does not list the ingredients.
Bartleby’s animal cakes are customizable, fully edible, totally delicious re-creations of all creatures great and small! Animal cakes can be dairy or vegan; each cake contains: Two layers of ice cream Two layers of a crumbled baked good Whipped cream or vegan buttercream frosting Cookies, chocolate, candy, cones, frosting, and whatever other tasty art supplies we can think of to construct your animal! After placing your order, please email a photo or inspiration image of the animal you want us to make to [email protected] . Due to the limitations of ice cream and our preference for flavor over looks, we don’t use fondant, gum paste, or other tools commonly used to make heavily styled baked cakes
Ask for the vegan or vegetarian version, the menu says they make one.
9 dishes
Give the gift of ice cream to someone you really, really like (it could even be yourself—you deserve it)! Pint subscriptions provide four pints of our superpremium, homemade ice cream per month to your designated recipient. You can pick the first four flavors, and from there, we’ll take them on a tour of our dip cases, providing a variety of year-round classics, seasonal specials, and limited batches. And we’ll make sure we never repeat a pint! * This gift will work best for recipients who eat dairy, as our vegan offerings are more limited. ** If you select delivery as the fulfillment method, you’ll be charged at checkout for the first delivery, and then we’ll send you an invoice for the remaining months’ delivery fees
The wedding cake of your dreams starts with the flavors you love. Mix, match, and make your ideal combination of ice cream, baked goods, frosting, and decorations! Each package includes: • Five flavors of ice cream, 4 oz. each • Three baked goods • Two flavors of frosting • Four decorations Off-menu requests, including Bartleby’s past seasonal flavors, can be accommodated for an additional fee. An in-person virtual consultation with our owner and chief cake decorator, Rachel, can be scheduled to accompany your tasting. Let us know below if you want us to reach out to schedule a consult!
The catered scoop or sundae bar of your dreams starts with the flavors you love. Mix, match, and make your ideal combination of our homemade ice cream and toppings! Each package includes: • Six flavors of ice cream, 4 oz. each For sundae bars, add your choice of: • Three baked goods • Five toppings Off-menu requests, including Bartleby’s past seasonal flavors, can be accommodated for an additional fee. An in-person virtual consultation with our owner Rachel can be scheduled to accompany your tasting. Let us know below if you want us to reach out to schedule a consult!
1 dish
Ask for oat, almond or soy milk instead of dairy.
1 dish